5 July 2021

Foodinho, a subsidiary of GlovoApp23, will have to amend the way it processes its riders’ data through a digital platform and verify that the algorithms used to book and assign orders for food and other products do not result into discrimination. The company was also fined EUR 2.6 million.

This decision by the Italian SA (Garante per la protezione dei dati personali) is the first one concerning riders and follows an initial set of inspections on the handling of employees’ data by the main food delivery companies in Italy.

The complex inquiries also concerned Foodinho, an Italy-based company, and led to finding several infringements of data protection legislation, the Italian law on employer-employee relations, and the recently enacted legislation to protect workers using digital platforms.

The Italian SA also initiated, for the first time, a joint operation with the Spanish SA (AEPD) under the terms of the GDPR to shed light on operation of the digital platform owned by the holding company, i.e., GlovoApp23.

Several serious infringements could be found with particular regard to the algorithms used to handle employees. For instance, the company had failed to adequately inform its employees on the functioning of the system and had not implemented suitable safeguards to ensure accuracy and fairness of the algorithmic results that were used to rate riders’ performance. Additionally, the company had no procedures in place to enforce the right to obtain human intervention, express one’s point of view and contest the decisions taken by way of those algorithms – which in some cases entailed the exclusion of riders from work assignments.

Accordingly, the Italian SA ordered the company to lay down measures to protect riders’ rights and freedoms with regard to automated decisions, including profiling.

Foodinho was ordered to check accuracy and relevance of the data used by the system – chats, emails and phone calls between riders and customer care, geolocation at 15-second intervals, mapping of routes, estimated and actual delivery time, details on the handling of current and past orders, feedback from customers and partners, device battery level, etc. . This is also intended to minimize the risk of errors and biases that might for instance result into reducing delivery assignments to certain riders or excluding a rider from the platform as such. The risk in question is also related to the rating system, which relies on the application of a mathematical formula carrying penalties for those riders who do not accept orders promptly or reject such orders, whilst riders accepting orders on schedule or delivering most orders are prioritized. The rating takes into account delivered orders, check-ins performed within each booked slot a few minutes after start of the slot, acceptance of the assigned order within 30 seconds.

The company will have to lay down measures preventing inappropriate and/or discriminatory applications of the reputational mechanisms based on the feedback from customers and business partners.

In calculating the 2.6 million EUR fine imposed on Foodinho because of the infringements found, the Italian SA also considered the poor cooperation provided by the company during the inquiries as well as the considerable number of the riders concerned in Italy – amounting to about 19,000 when the inspection was carried out. The Spanish company GlovoApp23 is the subject of a separate proceeding led by the AEPD in cooperation with the Italian SA.

The Italian SA set a 60-day deadline for Foodinho to start implementing the measures required in order to remedy the serious shortcomings it had found, whilst additional 90 days were granted to finalise the rehauling of the algorithms.

For further details, please consult the abstract of the Italian SA's order against Foodinho here

The original press release in Italian is available here

For further information, please contact the Italian SA: ufficiostampa@gpdp.it


The press release published here does not constitute official EDPB communication, nor an EDPB endorsement. This press release was originally published by the national supervisory authority and was published here at the request of the SA for information purposes. As the press release is represented here as it appeared on the SA's website or other channels of communication, the news item is only available in English or in the Member State's official language with a short introduction in English. Any questions regarding this press release should be directed to the supervisory authority concerned.